Click Butterfly for
Archive Table of Contents Archive
of Resistance:
Anti-anorexia/anti-bulimia Breaking
the Spell: Conversation with Jenny and
Ron David: Well, we were
going to meet last week but I understand that we almost lost
you. Ron: I had a heart attack
but it's not serious. David: What did you
think, Jenny, when you first heard about it? Were you so
sure it wasn't serious then? Jenny: Yah, I kind of
knew what was going on. However my feelings at that time
were not from a clinical point of view obviously. It was
from an emotional point of view. I wasn't interested in
knowing what was going on from the physical point of view.
Yah, he is recovered but he is supposed to go back for a
bypass. So, it's not really that simple. David: No...no! Were you
worried for your dad? Jenny: Reasonably . .
.yah. David: Ron, are you
worried for yourself? Ron: No, I just want to
avoid the surgery if I can. I am looking at other
alternatives. David: Jenny, I
understand from my brief conversations with your doctor and
yourself that anorexia started operating on you more over
this period of time and it had you collapse. You just told
me before we started recording that you have resolution to
act against Anorexia. Ron, would you please bear witness to
this? Jenny: Yep. .
. David: And I bet your
doctors, your parents, and your relatives have been trying
to tell you about their concerns for you for some time? So I
am wonderring why it is there is something so different
about you since we last met. When I talked to you on the
phone, you were like an anti-anorexic person. First of all,
what is this resolution you told me about? Jenny: One of my
resolutions is to really suppress the people who fuel the
anorexia. I believe these people are required to be
literally brought down. David: I'm all for that.
How are you acting against any such person or any such
force? Jenny: Well, at work I'm
a project manager. My boss is my only superior apart from
the COB. ˙I am working on a project of his right now with a
deadline of Oct.14th. My doctor has given me leave to
exactly that date. David: Three or four
weeks ago, my guess is that you would have told your doctor
that you would take leave only after the 14th
October? Jenny: Yah, I would have
certainly said that. But I am still doing one or two hours
at home. David:: There must be
more to it. You are glossing over what I take to be
significant. Ron, would you agree? Ron:
DEFINITELY! David: Three weeks ago,
she would have preferred to go to her death rather than not
completing the project under the deadline. She would have
been the 'dead' in the 'line'! WHY? WHY? Ron:
Yeh...yeh! Jenny: Like I told you
people like my parents, my PhD supervisor and a few people
at work are worth putting yourself on the line for or
jumping into the trenches for. But there are some people and
some institutions I might add, which are not worth giving up
your life for. David: Now this couldn't
just come out of the blue? Was it related to the threat to
Ron' s life? Jenny: Yes and my
collapse. But when I collapsed, I sort of brushed it away
and I went back to normal but when it happened to dad and I
was feeling very nauseous at work, it hit me quite strongly.
It really made me think! David: Anorexia wouldn't
have liked self-caring thoughts or being concerned about
your own welfare, would it? Were these unusual thoughts for
you? Jenny: Yes. David: Tell me how you
possibly could have thought these thoughts because they are
life-saving thoughts and not death thoughts? Jenny: Well, I know that
anorexia is always going to be out there in the world and
take the form of these people and these
institutions. David: I think saying you
can be free of anorexia would be like saying you can be free
of air. However, you can decide to breath fresh air as
opposed to polluted air! I am wonderring what you are
thinking of what I am thinking? Jenny: Yah, the world is
never going to be purged of anorexia. David: I hope you don't
mind me pressing a little bit. There still isn't enough for
me to understand how, even though anorexia has occupied your
life for so long, your mother's life and your aunt's life
for periods of time, you could just turn against it like
that. Surely it will .... Jenny: (interrupting)
COME BACK! David: COUNTER
ATTACK! Jenny: Yes, it could. It
could always try. David: It's not trying to
counter-attack RIGHT NOW? Jenny: Well, it doesn't
hold enough ground to counter-attack NOW!
(laughing) David: Really! Ron, I
know you have a remarkable daughter but I don't think I have
heard anything so forcefully stated for several years now.
Ron, we should listen carefully, shouldn't we? Jenny, do you
know what you are saying? Jenny: WHAT??? David: It's not that I
don't believe you because I have some sense of you but I am
still marveling and I mean that literally. The scare of what
you have done is something akin to saying several weeks ago
that you were finding it tiring walking the three miles from
your home to university and now you tell me you have scaled
Mt. Everest. And I'd like to appreciate it too! Jenny: OKAY. David: And I'd like other
people to hear about this from you. Jenny: Yep. David: You are telling me
it is not counter-attacking? Ron: It was trying a bit
yesterday evening. Jenny: It tried but
... Ron: She was at work with
her boss again. David: Did that give
anorexia the advantage for a little while? Can you explain
that so we can better understand how anorexia
operates? Jenny: I went to work
despite my leave just for a couple of hours or so. I went
there to help out. And then people starting making demands
and it turned nasty. So I said - 'I've got an ulcer and I am
on medical leave. I have to go!' And I just went and of
course no one stopped me. But when I cam home, I could
really feel the stress. I felt quite mutilated. David: I appreciate your
use of language. This is a very, very strong word. How did
you experience their demands on you as mutilating of
yourself and you body? Jenny: Well, it feels
like they are actually cutting through you. You actually
feel it like when I tried to help, they asked me to do more
and 'hey, you can ˙finish this off in another hour. .
.' David: They started
giving you some deadlines? Jenny: Yah! Ron: They said they
wanted it tomorrow in spite of her doctor's certificate for
2 week's leave. I don't know how they can demand a deadline.
I am going to speak to him when I get back to work. This is
illegal. David: I would like to
know for my own learning and other people who will come
after you . . . you returned home .. . anorexia had a
temporary advantage but you pulled yourself away from it? My
guess is that three weeks ago, that would have led to a
sweeping victory for anorexia? Ron: YAH! Jenny: YAH! David: How come? Did you
do it all by yourself? Was someone a support to you? Did
some anti-anorexia ideas enter your mind? Did what you refer
to as your 'soul' come forward and prevail? Was it one or
more of those things? Jenny: Well, I just felt
that I wasn't ready to be sad anymore. I understand now that
sadness and remorse - these are not very nice emotions but
they are quite respectful and should be reserved for things
li }ke what happened to Dad. And I feel sad. That experience
of sadness was like a clear and filtered experience of
sadness compared to the stupid sadness and remorse at
work. David: Do you mean that
the sadness and remorse you felt for your Dad's heart attack
showed you that this was what was really important in your
life? Jenny: Yah, it showed me
that this was a part of life that was quite
significant. Ron: I guess what she is
trying to say is that sadness and remorse are feelings that
should be reserved for occasions that call for them. They
are not to be used in everyday life. Jenny: Yah, I should be
brushing off what happens at work instead of feeling sad.
What happened to Dad and what might have happened to my
family is something I genuinely feel sad about. Ron: This is a remarkable
shift in her. David: Yah, I am 'knocked
off my perch' here. This is quite breath-taking, isn't
it? Jenny: It is
too! David: Can you sense my
amazement? Jenny: Yes, I
can. David: Are you as amazed
as I am? Or am I more amazed than you are? This could be a
turning point in your life? Jenny: IT IS! I would
certainly say that it is! Ron: If she can hold on
to it. David: A turning point
merely points you in a different direction. It does mean
that everything goes away Ron: That's right. OF
COURSE! David: I'd compare it to
the Allied invasion of Normandy in 1944. That turned the
tide of the war but just because they landed, Berlin didn't
fall. Ron: No. David: If anything, from
there on the war was fought more fiercely. We are now at war
whereas before everyone was trying to tell you - 'Please
fight for your life! Please fight for your life because we
cannot fight anorexia for you' I can assure you we can be
with you. And I would very much like to do that. Jenny, is
this a matter of your prudence? Do you think if your dad
¡hadn't had his life threatened, that this would not
have happened? Jenny: That is exactly
what I thought myself. The minute he went to the hospital, I
thought that we had hit rock bottom. And we just had to come
back. There was a stage there where either we all cracked
our heads or we bounced back? David: What does your
mother think about what you are doing? Jenny: She has started
taking life a bit easier....slowing down. Do you think so,
Dad? Ron: Yah, slightly
relaxed now. DEFINITELY. Quite a bit more relaxed than
before. We are trying to c-operate as much as is physically
possible.. Jenny: She still has to
look after Dad and me. David: Does that make her
busy? Ron: Quite busy but she
is quite a bit more relaxed because Jenny is out of
danger. David: Was there anything
in our previous meetings or the letters that laid the
foundations for this? Jenny: The experiences of
other women in the letters you gave me...THEIR PATHS TO
FREEDOM...they were quite significant too.

??/??/98
David
Epston
![]() © Dean Lobovits, David Epston, Jennifer Freeman narrative@attbi.com Date Last Modified: 4/21/2k |